Rob Goffee and Gareth Jones built a body of work on one blunt question: why should anyone be led by you? Owners rarely have it put to them, because owning the business means nobody has to ask it out loud.
Ownership gives you authority but not followers. You can compel attendance, timekeeping and a fair day's work. You cannot compel the extra call on a Friday afternoon, the mistake flagged early rather than quietly buried, or the good person who turns down a better offer because they want to see this through. That is the discretionary layer, and part of your margin depends on it.
What are the four behaviours?
Goffee and Jones identified four things running through leaders people chose to follow. All four can be learned.
Show some weakness, selectively
Admitting a real flaw stops people hunting for the hidden one. You choose a weakness that is genuine, that they can already see, and that is not load-bearing. An owner saying “I am hopeless at remembering names, tell me twice” builds credit. An owner saying “I do not know if we will make payroll” transfers the weight of the business onto people who cannot carry it.
Read the room in real time
Good leaders pick up the mood of a group and adjust while they are still speaking. It is a matter of watching faces instead of your notes, and being willing to abandon what you planned to say when it is clearly the wrong thing for the room in front of you.
Tough empathy
Care about the person and care about the work, and refuse to trade one for the other. Tough empathy is giving somebody what they need rather than what they want. It sounds like: “I think you are in the wrong role, and I have watched you be unhappy in it for a year. Let us talk about what the right one looks like, here or somewhere else.”
Be different, on purpose
Leaders who get followed have something distinctive and do not sand it off. It might be an obsession with detail, a background nobody else in the trade has, or a habit of asking the awkward question in supplier meetings. Many owners spend years trying to look like a proper managing director.
What are people looking for?
The other half of the model is what followers want, and it explains much of what owners describe as a retention problem.
People want authenticity, so they can stop guessing which version of you they are getting today. They want significance: what they did this week visibly mattered to somebody. They want some excitement, a sense that this is going somewhere. And they want community, the feeling of being part of a group rather than a payroll number.
Little of that list is pay. Pay gets people through the door and keeps them for a while, but it does not produce the discretionary layer.
How to use it this month
- Write your answer to the question in three sentences. Why should anyone be led by you specifically, as opposed to a competent manager on the same salary? If the answer is “because I own it”, that is the gap to work on.
- Name one weakness you can afford to show: real, visible, not load-bearing. Say it out loud once this week, without the joke you normally attach to it.
- Test yourself against the four wants. Take one person in your team and ask whether they have had authenticity, significance, excitement and community from you in the last month.
- Have one tough empathy conversation — the one you have been putting off. Lead with what you have noticed rather than what you have decided, and stay in the room after you have said it.
- Stop sanding off the difference. Identify the thing about how you work that you have been apologising for. If it damages nobody, keep it and use it deliberately.
- Ask three people what they think you stand for. Compare their answers with what you intend.
The mistakes to watch for
The first mistake is hearing “be yourself” as a licence for whatever mood you walked in with. The full instruction is be yourself, more, with skill, and the last two words are the ones owners skip. Skill means choosing which parts of yourself the situation needs, in the way a good tradesman chooses a tool.
The second is the fake weakness. “I care too much.” “I am a bit of a perfectionist.” Everybody in the room identifies a humblebrag within seconds, and it shows you will manage the truth when it suits you.
The third is doing this only when something has gone wrong. The four behaviours matter more in an ordinary month than in a crisis, because an ordinary month is when people quietly decide what kind of leader you are.
Questions to ask yourself
- Out of 10, how confident are you that your best people would follow you if they had a free choice?
- What is the last thing you admitted to your team that cost you something to say?
- Which of the four wants — authenticity, significance, excitement or community — is thinnest in your business right now?
- What are you doing to look like a proper managing director that nobody asked for?
This sits at the heart of Leadership Coaching. Read it with Team Development, which is what followership looks like at the level of a group, and the Will/Skill Model, which is how you spend your leadership attention. The full set is in the Mindsets library.
Get the next one in your inbox
One guide for business owners each week. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Frequently asked questions
Is this about charisma?
No. Goffee and Jones were describing behaviours rather than personality, and all four can be practised by somebody with no natural presence at all. Showing a real weakness, adjusting while you are still speaking because you are watching faces, giving people what they need rather than what they want, and refusing to sand off what makes you distinctive are all things you decide to do. Owners who are quiet or awkward in front of a room often do this better than polished performers, because the whole point is that people are following somebody recognisably real.
Does admitting weakness undermine authority?
Only if you pick the wrong weakness. The rule is that it should be genuine, already visible to the people you are telling, and not load-bearing. Admitting you are hopeless with names or that you dislike presenting builds credit, because it stops people hunting for the flaw you are hiding. Admitting you do not know whether payroll will clear transfers the weight of the business onto people who cannot carry it. The version that damages you most is the fake weakness. Everybody recognises a humblebrag immediately, and it proves you will manage the truth when it suits you.
What is tough empathy in practice?
Caring about the person and caring about the work, and refusing to trade one for the other. In practice it means saying the difficult thing and then staying in the room. It sounds like telling somebody you think they are in the wrong role, that you have watched them be unhappy in it, and that you want to talk about what the right one looks like, here or elsewhere. Many owners can manage tough, often late and by email. Fewer manage empathy without softening the message until it disappears. Doing both in the same conversation is what makes people trust the feedback they get from you.