To price for profit, work backwards from the profit the business needs rather than forwards from what it costs you to deliver. Costs give you a floor, not a price. Then run one piece of arithmetic before you do anything else: what a 10 per cent price rise does to your net profit, and how many clients you could lose at the higher price and still be exactly as profitable. For most small businesses the answers are startling — the profit roughly doubles, and you could lose around one client in five and be no worse off.
Pricing is the highest-leverage decision in most small businesses and it gets less attention than almost anything else. A price increase goes straight to the bottom line. A revenue increase brings costs, capacity pressure and more of your time with it, and often delivers a fraction of the profit for several times the effort. Most owners underprice — not because they ran the numbers and concluded their prices were right, but because they are nervous about losing work, being seen as expensive, or having a conversation they would rather avoid.
Why is cost-plus a floor rather than a price?
Starting with your costs and adding a margin tells you the point below which you should not go. It does not tell you what to charge. The question is not "what do I need to cover my costs?" but "what is this worth to the client?" Those are frequently very different numbers, and the gap between them is where your margin lives.
Clients are not buying your hours. They are buying an outcome — a problem avoided, a decision made properly, a job finished on time. The price of that outcome has very little to do with how long it took you, and pricing on input is the most common way small businesses give away value they have already created.
A 10 per cent price rise carries no delivery cost, no extra capacity and no additional risk. There is nothing else available to a small business that improves profit that much for that little.
What does a 10 per cent price move actually do?
Illustrative figures, and worth running with your own. A business turns over £480,000 across 100 jobs at £4,800 each. Direct costs are £2,880 a job, so £288,000 in total. Gross profit is £192,000. Overheads are £150,000. Net profit is £42,000.
Now put prices up 10 per cent, and assume every client stays:
- Price per job £5,280, revenue £528,000.
- Direct costs are unchanged at £288,000 — you are doing the same work.
- Gross profit £240,000. Overheads still £150,000.
- Net profit £90,000. It has more than doubled on a 10 per cent price move.
Now the more useful question: how many clients could you lose and still be no worse off? Gross profit per job rises from £1,920 to £2,400. To hold £192,000 of gross profit you need 80 jobs rather than 100. You could lose one client in five, be exactly as profitable, and do 20 per cent less work.
Run it the other way and the discounting habit looks different too. Drop prices 10 per cent and gross profit per job falls to £1,440. To stand still you now need 133 jobs instead of 100 — a third more work for the same profit, with a third more delivery risk, a third more admin and a third more of your time. That is the arithmetic behind the dangers of discounting, and it is why pricing deserves a day of your attention a year. You can run these numbers on your own business with our profit improvement calculator.
What does underpricing really cost you?
The obvious cost is margin: lower prices mean more volume for the same profit, which puts pressure on capacity, quality and you.
The less obvious cost is who you attract. Cheap prices bring price-sensitive clients, and price-sensitive clients are the hardest to serve. They query every invoice, move as soon as someone cheaper appears, and take up disproportionate time relative to what they pay. Underpricing does not only cost you margin — it selects the clients who will make the rest of the business harder, and then fills your capacity with them so there is no room for better work when it arrives.
How do you set a profitable price?
Work backwards from profit, not forwards from cost. Decide the net profit the business needs to make. Add overheads. Add direct costs. Divide by the number of jobs or clients you can realistically deliver at a standard you would defend. That gives you a floor.
Then look at value. What does the client gain, avoid or save? What is the alternative costing them? What would they pay someone with a stronger reputation? The ceiling is usually well above the floor, and most small businesses sit close to the floor without ever having checked where the ceiling is. Write the value case in one paragraph before you quote — if you cannot make the case to yourself, you will not make it to a client, and you will discount at the first hesitation.
How do you raise prices without losing the business?
Give reasonable notice — 30 days for ongoing work, longer for annual arrangements. Be clear and unapologetic. State the new price, the date it applies from, and one short line of explanation. Do not over-explain: length reads as guilt, and guilt invites negotiation.
Some clients will leave, typically the ones who were only there for the price. A considered, well-communicated increase rarely produces the exodus owners fear, and the arithmetic above shows you can absorb a fair number of departures before you are worse off.
If you have no idea where your prices sit, the most reliable test is to raise them on new business first and watch what happens. If nobody hesitates, they were too low. If some push back and most accept, you have found the market. If you lose most enquiries, you have learned something specific and cheap about the segment you are serving. Saying the number without softening it is a skill in itself — state your price covers the delivery, and our guide to owner confidence covers why it is so often the sticking point.
The checklist
- Work out gross profit per job or per client. Revenue minus the costs that vary with the work. If you cannot, that is the first job.
- Run the 10 per cent model on your own numbers, both up and down.
- Calculate your break-even client loss. How many can you afford to lose after an increase before you are worse off?
- Rank clients by gross profit, not revenue. The list is usually not what you expect.
- Identify the bottom tenth and decide: reprice, rescope or release.
- Set the floor from a target profit, not from costs plus a habit.
- Write the value case in one paragraph — what the client gains, avoids or saves.
- Apply new prices to new enquiries immediately. No notice period required, and it tells you the market answer within weeks.
- Diarise an annual pricing review so it stops being an event and becomes a routine.
- Stop discounting to close. Change the scope instead if you need to move the number.
The questions to sit with
- When did you last raise prices, and what actually happened?
- Out of ten, how confident are you saying your price out loud without adding a qualification?
- Which clients would you not take on again at the price they currently pay?
- If you were 20 per cent more expensive than you are today, what would have to be true about the business? What is stopping you making it true?
Pricing sits at the centre of business coaching for a reason: it is the fastest route to a materially different set of numbers, and the obstacle is almost never the arithmetic. Where the margin problem runs deeper than the price list, our guide to improving margins takes it further, and the monthly business review is what stops the drift returning quietly over the next two years.
Get the next one in your inbox
One practical, plain-English guide for business owners each week. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
Frequently asked questions
My market is price-sensitive and competitive — does this still apply?
Some markets genuinely are, and in those the answer is usually to change what you sell rather than to hold the price down until there is nothing left. But most owners believe their market is price-sensitive because they have only ever heard from the clients who chose on price — the ones who chose on something else never mentioned it. Before accepting it as fact, find out what your competitors actually charge rather than what you assume they charge, and ask three recent clients why they picked you. The word price comes up far less often than owners expect, and when it does it is rarely first.
Should I put prices up for everyone at once?
Not usually. Apply the new price to new enquiries immediately, because that costs you nothing and tells you within weeks how the market responds. Then move existing clients in waves, starting with the least profitable — you learn from the first wave and the risk stays contained. An across-the-board increase on the same day makes every client's conversation happen at once, which is the version most likely to produce a bad week and a hasty reversal. The exception is a formal annual uplift written into your terms, which is simpler to apply to everyone on the same date.
What about long-standing clients who have never had an increase?
They are usually the least profitable accounts you have, and the conversation is overdue rather than unreasonable. Your costs have risen every year since that price was set and both of you know it. Give proper notice, state the new figure and the date, and keep the explanation to one line — long justifications read as guilt and invite a negotiation you did not need to have. If the relationship really cannot carry a rise after several years of none, that is worth knowing too, because it means the account has been subsidised by the rest of your clients for a long time.
How often should prices change?
Review annually and change whenever the review says it is justified. Put the date in the diary so it becomes a routine rather than an event you have to work yourself up to. Businesses that never review end up facing one large, difficult increase every five years instead of a small, unremarkable one each year — and the large version is far more likely to lose clients, because it arrives as a shock rather than as the way things work here. Reviewing does not commit you to raising anything. It commits you to knowing where you stand.
What if I raise prices and lose more clients than the arithmetic allowed for?
First check what you actually lost. The break-even number is measured in gross profit, not client count, so losing six of your smallest accounts is not the same event as losing two of your largest. Rank the departures by gross profit before you conclude anything. If the loss is real, you have learned something specific and recoverable: the increase was too large in one step, or it landed without a value case, or that segment genuinely will not pay it. None of those require going back to the old price for everyone. Hold the new price for new enquiries, where the feedback is cheapest, and where a client relationship is worth keeping, negotiate the scope rather than the number. Retreating on price across the board teaches every client that your prices are an opening bid.